By Sadie McInnis
Anywhere between 30,000 and 200,000 people are homeless in Canada, with another 1.7 million unable to afford adequate, suitable shelter. Winnipeg in particular has a history of housing shortages and inner-city poverty. In 2015 it was estimated that on a given night in the city there were at least 1,400 people experiencing homelessness. Winnipeg is also home to the largest urban Indigenous population in Canada and poverty rates among the highest in the country.
Unfortunately, much of the research on homelessness in Canada lacks a comprehensive gender-based analysis. It’s time we pay attention to the unique experience of homeless women, and also take into account other identity-based barriers to housing and services that women face.
1. Housing and supports must be accessible to mothers
As author Susan Scott writes in her 2007 book All Our Sisters: Stories of Homeless Women in Canada, “The presence of children can make it difficult for mothers to take any accommodation that happens to come up in the right price bracket. They have to think about safety, accessibility to schools, grocery stores, bus routes, and other amenities– if the landlord accepts children in the first place.” That means mothers’ concerns for their children may often trump their most affordable option for accommodation. Furthermore, mothers with children living in precarious housing who struggle with addictions may avoid entering drug treatment or emergency shelters for fear that their children will be removed from their care. These barriers are especially concerning in light of the fact that female lone-parent families are one of the demographics facing the highest rates of poverty in Canada.
2. Women are more vulnerable to hidden homelessness
For a number of reasons, women’s homelessness is often hidden—sometimes as a result of experiences with violence. The Homelessness Hub’s 2013 report on homelessness in Canada describes hidden homelessness as: “staying with a violent partner because she can’t afford to leave; being bound to a pimp or a dealer; couch-surfing from one relative to another; or living in unhygienic and unsafe buildings and/or over-crowded conditions.” This means women’s struggle to gain and maintain housing is often not visible. However, in March 2013, of the individuals who used an inner city Winnipeg community-based Tenant Landlord Cooperation program that advocates on tenant’s behalf, 86% were female and 81% were Indigenous.
3. Women are most often homeless as the result of some form of abuse
In 2010, 71% of women staying in shelters across Canada reported abuse as their reason for seeking refuge. In the Social Planning Council of Winnipeg’s forthcoming gender analysis of the 2015 Winnipeg Street Census, nearly 60% of women cited family conflict, breakdown or violence as the reason for their first experience of homelessness, compared with 40% of men.
For many women, concerns for safety continue while homeless. It has been reported that as many as 91% of homeless women in Canada have experienced assault in their lifetime.
4. Multiple identities
Where women are marginalized along multiple identity axes, their likelihood of experiencing poverty and homelessness increases drastically, and their ability to access appropriate services declines. Women of Colour in general, and in particular Black and Indigenous women, face sexism which intersects with racism, classism, and colonialism, resulting in a high risk of homelessness. This can also be exacerbated by refugee or immigration status, as women often lack structural supports upon arrival in Canada.
Overwhelmingly, Indigenous women are the most impacted by poverty and homelessness, and are also the most likely to have their children apprehended by Child and Family Services. The overrepresentation of Indigenous children in the child welfare system is one of the many residual impacts of Canada’s colonial history, and one facet of Canada’s ongoing colonial project. According to Amnesty International, Indigenous women “have been pushed into dangerous situations of extreme poverty, homelessness, and prostitution that make it easy for men, both Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal, to be extremely violent towards them.”
LGBTQ people are also overrepresented among the homeless, and are estimated to account for as much as 40% of the homeless population. Trans youth are particularly vulnerable. One in three trans youth will be rejected from a shelter while homeless, as a result of transphobic shelter policies that police gender presentation and expression.
The community organizations guiding CCPA-Manitoba’s annual research collaboration, The State of the Inner City Report, have prioritized the need to better understand women’s homelessness in Winnipeg, and how we can bring it to an end. This year’s report will focus specifically on women’s experiences of homelessness, and will map out—with the participation of women from the inner city—how public policy can make housing more accessible to women.